Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Beef Carpaccio
Braciole Orecchiette
Pappardelle Amici
Pappardelle Bolognese
About
Cafe Amici Downtown
Welcome to Cafe Amici Downtown, a charming Italian establishment nestled in the heart of Sarasota, FL, at 1371 Main St. Renowned for its authentic Italian flavors and warm atmosphere, this eatery has become a favorite for both locals and visitors alike. With a passionate team boasting deep Italian roots, your dining experience here feels like a journey to Italy—right down to the language spoken by the friendly staff.
At Cafe Amici, the menu is a delightful exploration of traditional Italian cuisine. Start your evening with their expertly crafted antipasti, like the Beef Carpaccio, delicately drizzled with oil and lemon, or the savory Antipasto Rustico, featuring a luxurious selection of Italian meats and cheese ideal for sharing. For the salad lovers, the Insalata Mista di Campo offers a refreshing blend of organic greens and balsamic vinaigrette that prepares your palate for the entrees to come.
- Entrees: A highlight of the Cafe Amici experience is undoubtedly their pasta dishes. The Tortelloni Alla Vodka is a sublime combination of beef veal tortellini enveloped in a rich vodka sauce, leaving you craving more. If you seek the taste of the sea, the Linguine Clams elegantly combines sautéed littlenecks with garlic and oil—an homage to the coastal flavors of Italy.
- A Cozy Atmosphere: Guests rave about the ambiance; it’s intimate yet lively, making it perfect for both casual dinners and special celebrations. The restaurant buzzes with excitement, especially during peak hours, enhancing your dining experience with a vibrant social vibe.
- Special Celebrations: Whether you're planning a birthday or an anniversary, Cafe Amici Downtown offers personalized touches that make special events unforgettable, such as private rooms with dancing options.
What sets Cafe Amici apart is not only the top-notch quality of the food but also the commitment to providing a genuine Italian experience. Diners like Vincent D'Accolti emphasize the authenticity of the establishment, while Debbie Turner delights in their excellent wine selection and memorable culinary showcases, such as their innovative Margarita-making bicycle!
In conclusion, each visit to Cafe Amici Downtown promises a feast of flavors, memories, and a little slice of Italy in Sarasota. It's no wonder this place is receiving glowing reviews from patrons who appreciate not just good food but a community-driven dining experience. Swing by and prepare your taste buds for an authentic Italian adventure that you won’t soon forget!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Authentic, Authentic , Off the boat Italians from hostess , waiter, chef and owners ... we ordered in Italian .... Just had pizza and dessert but will def be back for full entrees ,,, place is small and was packed so call ahead ”
“ We had a great experience dining here on St Patrick’s Day. The best tomahawk steak that I have had in town. Excellent wine selection too. This is also a wonderful place to celebrate a special event. We had our own room with a dance floor and DJ! If I could add a video you could see the bicycle that you ride that blends a Margarita! It really works. Ask for the owner Massimo he’s a class act. ”
“ We arrived early on avDaturday, right before 6 pm rush. Service was great and foidvtop notch. By 630 the place was loud and fun. I especially liked thecTV tuned to the Gators beating LSU. Added unexpected bonus. ”
“ Always fantastic - great bar, wine list, and food! High end Italian, this is well prepared, gourmet Italian cuisine in a very nice atmosphere. ”
“ We finally got to try it and loved it. Fresh food. Great wine selection. Elegant, cozy, and friendly service. To top off the great meal, they had something I couldn't find in FL since I moved here in 2016. A Ricotta cheese cake. It's a bit different than what you get up north, but close enough to make it all worthwhile. I'm a fan. ”
“ We went here for a nice romantic dinner on Valentine's day 2-14-25. The service was great and everything we ordered was delicious.. I highly recommend this restaurant..It is one of my favorite places to eat at... I cannot wait to go back again.... ”
“ Real Italian food for people who love authentic flavorful food. As good as what we had in Italy! Bread with dipping oil and spices, Caesar salad branzino and filet .. all mouth watering and topped by amaretto cake .. so good I forgot to take pics ! Service was on point and respectful Ambiance was warm and Italian! Can't wait to come back! Highly recommend ! ”
“ My Sister and I went to Cafe Amici and had a fabulous dinner! The food was amazing and the service was exceptional!, Our waiter was great, very knowledgeable about the food, answered all our questions and gave us great suggestions about what to order The place was very busy but we didn’t have wait for a table The entire experience was very positive If you’re looking for a great Italian restaurant, you won’t be disappointed ”